There is no doubt that trees provide tremendous benefits to humans and the planet. From carbon sequestration and air quality improvement to soil health and supporting biodiversity, trees support life on earth in a myriad of ways. Therefore surely the more trees the better, right? Unfortunately it's not quite as simple as that. In recent years tree planting schemes have gained immense popularity as a 'straightforward' solution to a variety of environmental problems, with many organisations jumping on the bandwagon, such as for carbon offsetting projects. However, these initiatives are not the silver bullet they are often touted to be. A deeper examination reveals a wide range of issues to consider when embarking on tree planting/restoration projects.
Some of these issues include:
- 🌱 Monocultures and Biodiversity Loss - One of the most significant problems with many tree planting schemes is the tendency to create monocultures, where only one species is planted over a large area. While this approach can be cost-effective and easier to manage, it also leads to loss of biodiversity. Monocultures have little resilience to pests and diseases, and they do not provide the diverse habitats needed by wildlife species. In the worst cases, the planting of non-native species can result in them becoming invasive and lead to severe disruption of local ecosystems. This loss of biodiversity results in the loss of the benefits people derive from the natural world (ecosystem services). https://www.nature.org/en-us/newsroom/biodiversitree-experiment/
- 🌱 Inappropriate site/species selection- planting trees in the wrong place or planting inappropriate species can cause native biodiversity to be displaced and can degrade ecosystems. Therefore it is essential that sites and species are selected to enhance or protect native biodiversity. Poor practices can turn ecosystems into "green deserts" that lack ecological value. https://usercontent.one/wp/www.biodiversitystandard.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/1.1-The-Global-Biodiversity-Standard-Manual-for-assessment-and-best-practices.pdf?media=1647864625
- 🌱 Lack of Long-Term Planning- Tree planting projects require a long term approach with sustained care and maintenance to ensure survival and growth. Many schemes focus on the initial planting phase without sufficient resources for ongoing care, such as watering, protection from animals, and disease management. This lack of planning results in low survival rates of newly planted trees, undermining the project's goals. https://www.worldagroforestry.org/blog/2021/07/13/speaking-trees-why-so-many-restoration-projects-fail
- 🌱 Social and Economic Issues- Large-scale tree planting projects can sometimes lead to the displacement of indigenous people and small-scale farmers. Involving local communities in the planning and implementation process is crucial for the success and sustainability of projects. Ignoring these aspects can lead to social unrest and economic issues for those who depend on the land. https://news.mongabay.com/2008/09/monoculture-tree-plantations-are-green-deserts-not-forests-say-activists/
- 🌱 Misleading Carbon Offsetting Claims - Many tree planting initiatives are marketed as simple solutions for carbon offsetting. However, the actual carbon sequestration potential of trees can be overestimated, especially if they do not reach maturity or are planted in unsuitable conditions. Furthermore, focusing solely on tree planting can detract from the urgent need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the first place, 'offsetting' should be a last resort. https://www.smithschool.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2024-02/Oxford-Principles-for-Net-Zero-Aligned-Carbon-Offsetting-revised-2024.pdf
🌲 Types of tree planting:
Something else to consider is the fact that there are many types of tree planting schemes with varying end goals. It is important that before engaging with a project you work out what you are looking to achieve and what type of project you want to be involved with.
For example:
🌿 a single species plantation can be helpful for local communities short-term to provide firewood and food but provides very little environmental benefit (and could be detrimental),
🌿 agroforestry planting can be both beneficial for local communities and biodiversity.
Ecosystem restoration may include tree planting of native species in degraded habitats (such as land previously used for mining or agriculture) but is also likely to require other interventions to be successful. Other types of tree planting schemes include:
🌿 urban tree planting (which can improve air quality, reduce urban heat islands and have social benefits),
🌿 riparian buffer planting (planting alongside waterways to reduce erosion, filter pollutants and provide habitat for wildlife) and
🌿 afforestation (planting new forests where they did not exist previously).
Additionally, it is important to consider the fact that tree planting isn't always the most efficient or effective solution, protecting existing forests or allowing natural regeneration (passive restoration) of forests can often yield the best results.
Tree planting schemes can have significant positive impacts on the environment, but they must be done in a responsible manner, addressing the issues outlined above. Accreditation schemes such as the Global Biodiversity Standard (developed by Botanic Gardens Conservation International https://www.biodiversitystandard.org/) establishes guidelines and best practices for biodiversity assessment and management in tree planting and restoration projects. The standard emphasises using native, threatened, and rare species, along with robust monitoring, evaluation, and adaptive biodiversity management. Such tools are invaluable if tree planting and restoration efforts are to have a positive environmental impact.
New research is also constantly evolving showing the benefits of trees for the environment, for example this new research showing that as well as sequestering carbon, the bark of trees also absorbs methane - another significant greenhouse gas: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/07/240724123005.htm.
In summary, while trees planting schemes have great potential for good, they must combine the considerations of biodiversity, local communities, and carbon capture in order to prevent them from inadvertently causing harm to our world’s ecosystems. To ensure positive outcomes, tree planting projects must be carefully planned and managed, incorporating best practices and guidelines such as those established by the Global Biodiversity Standard. By doing so, we can harness the true potential of tree planting to contribute to a healthier, more sustainable planet.
You have come to the place for thought leadership.
